Molina v. SEIU, Local 668
CASE SUMMARY
In January 2018, Francisco Molina and others within his bargaining unit were asked to sign new union membership cards. At the time, the SEIU informed membership that it needed new cards because the existing cards were “invalid” and the new cards would be “litigation proof.” The new cards would obligate members to pay dues, regardless of membership status—that is, even if they were no longer members.
Mr. Molina, who had once been a shop steward, refused to sign the new membership card and urged others to read the language in the card and make a decision for themselves. Union leadership believed that he was steering others, including new hires, away from union membership. After Janus v. AFSCME, Council 31, Mr. Molina became more vocal in his opposition to the union, even addressing the Lehigh County Commissioners in a public comment session.
By letter to the SEIU, dated July 16, 2018, Mr. Molina resigned from Local 668 and demanded that dues deductions stop immediately. He copied his employer and obtained return receipts.
Francisco Molina v. Pennsylvania Social Service Union, Service Employees International Union, Local 668; Stephen Catanese, in his official capacity as President of Pennsylvania Social Service Union, Service Employees International Union, Local 668; Lehigh County Board of Commissioners; Lehigh County Office of Children and Youth Services; Phil Armstrong, in his official capacity as County Executive of Lehigh County; and M. Judith Johnston, in her official capacity as Director of Human Resources of Lehigh County
The case has been filed in the United States District Court for the Middle District of Pennsylvania.
With Millions in Dues at Stake Across US, One Man Fights His Union for a Refund
September 20, 2019 |
He Tried to Quit His Union. The Law Didn’t Let Him, and He Lost His Government Job Instead.
May 13, 2019 |
For union members, knowledge is power
March 17, 2019 |
SEIU Plays Hardball
January 25, 2019 |
Former Lehigh County social worker files lawsuit over withheld union dues
January 13, 2019 |
Worker Sues for Right to Resign from SEIU
January 8, 2019 |
SEIU 668: The Purple People-Eater
January 8, 2019 |
Social worker sues union, says they violated constitutional rights
January 7, 2019 |
LEHIGH COUNTY COMMISSIONERS Worker opposed to union dues withdrawal
July 10, 2018 |
Lehigh County employee alleges harassment by union
June 28, 2018 |
Lehigh County prepares for union shake up following Supreme Court ruling
June 28, 2018 |
Supreme Court ruling on union dues already shaking things up in Lehigh Valley
June 28, 2018 |
Press Releases
Allentown Social Worker Sues Union for Violating Constitutional Rights
January 9, 2019
Press Release
October 8, 2019
Court Documents
Complaint
January 7, 2019
First Amended Complaint
February 11, 2019
Union Defendants’ Motion to Dismiss
March 4, 2019
Union Defendants’ Memo in Support of Motion to Dismiss
March 4, 2019
County Defendant’s Motion to Dismiss First Amended Complaint
March 4, 2019
County Defendant’s Brief in Support of Motion to Dismiss
March 4, 2019
Opinion re Motions to Dismiss
July 18, 2019
Union Defendant’s Supplemental Brief
August 1, 2019
County Defendant’s Supplemental Brief
August 1, 2019
Plaintiff’s Brief in Response to Defendants’ Supplemental Briefs
August 15, 2019
Order Requiring Defendants to File Answer to Amended Complaint
August 21, 2019
County Defendant’s Answer to Amended Complaint
September 10, 2019
Union Defendants’ Answer to Amended Complaint
September 11, 2019
Union Defendants’ Motion for Summary Judgment
October 4, 2019
Union Defendants’ Brief in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
October 8, 2019
County Defendant’s Amended Motion for Summary Judgment
October 8, 2019
Plaintiff’s Brief in Opposition to Motions for Summary Judgment
October 18, 2019